Scotland National Team

Scottish Football: A Broken System That Needs Fixing

Scottish football is in crisis. The league structure is outdated, TV deals are laughable, and youth development is stagnant. Fans are desperate for change, but the decision-makers continue to bury their heads in the sand. Joe Quinn, a former SPFL scout, has had enough. His proposal isn’t just a tweak to the system—it’s a complete overhaul. The question is, will Scottish football finally listen, or will self-interest and inaction win again? The Root of the Problem: A Game Run by Self-Preservation Scottish football is a closed shop. Quinn argues that change doesn’t happen because too many people in power benefit from keeping things exactly as they are. Whenever real reform is proposed, clubs and officials close ranks, protecting their own positions rather than the health of the game. Fans already know the issues: the league is predictable and stale, smaller clubs get a raw deal, Scottish talent is leaving in droves, and the women’s game is consistently underfunded and ignored. Quinn’s proposal isn’t just another discussion paper—it’s a radical blueprint to drag Scottish football into the modern era. But will those in charge finally step aside for progress? The 14-14-14 League Model: Genuine Reform or a New Coat of Paint? One of Quinn’s most controversial ideas is a 14-14-14 league structure designed to increase competition, fairness, and financial stability. The potential benefits are clear: fewer repetitive fixtures, proper promotion and relegation battles, and more clubs at the top level. On paper, it makes sense. But history tells us good ideas don’t always make it past the SPFL boardroom. Mid-table clubs happy with the status quo will fight this to the bitter end. The SPFL has a habit of discussing reform, only to back down when it matters most. Will this time be different? Ditching Gambling Sponsors: Ethical Stand or Financial Suicide? Scottish football is swimming in gambling sponsorships. Betting logos are plastered across shirts, advertising boards, and broadcasts. Quinn’s plan calls for an outright ban, following the example set by the English Premier League. The moral argument? Clear-cut. Gambling addiction destroys lives, and football shouldn’t be complicit in feeding the problem. The financial reality? A nightmare. Clubs, particularly those outside the Premiership, rely on gambling sponsorships to stay afloat. If the SPFL cuts ties with the industry, where does the replacement funding come from? Quinn believes it’s the right move in the long term, but without a clear financial alternative, this could cripple smaller clubs. The League Cup: Time to Stop the Snoozefest Quinn is clear on this: the League Cup group stage is a glorified pre-season exercise. Fans aren’t engaged, clubs don’t take it seriously, and the format is uninspiring. His solution? Scrap the groups, return to a straight knockout competition, and inject real jeopardy and excitement back into the tournament. It’s a simple, logical fix. Whether the SPFL will embrace it is another matter entirely. Youth Development & Women’s Football: Time for Real Investment Scottish football prides itself on producing top talent. But in reality, Quinn believes the system is failing young players. The best prospects leave Scotland at the first opportunity, the women’s game grows despite, not because of, governing body support, and clubs treat youth and women’s football as an afterthought rather than a priority. His proposal calls for real, sustained investment—not just PR soundbites and token gestures. If Scottish football wants a strong future, it has to stop relying on the accidental emergence of “golden generations.” TV Deals: Why Does Scotland Keep Selling Itself Short? Scottish football’s TV contracts are, frankly, embarrassing. Sky Sports cherry-picks matches and does the bare minimum to promote them, clubs earn a fraction of what smaller European leagues generate from broadcasting deals, and fans are either overcharged or locked out entirely. Quinn demands a more aggressive approach to negotiating TV rights. Germany and other European nations offer free-to-air matches. Why is Scotland still accepting scraps? According to Quinn, the SPFL’s usual excuse is “It’s the best deal we can get.” He disagrees. In his view, Scottish football’s leaders don’t fight hard enough for a better deal. Will Anything Actually Change? Scottish football has heard big ideas before. We’ve seen bold proposals, promising plans, and endless discussions. And yet, nothing changes. This time, though, the pressure is mounting. Fans are growing restless. The game is losing relevance. If the SPFL and SFA continue to ignore these problems, they risk losing an entire generation of supporters. So, will Quinn’s plan finally force real action? Or will it be another great idea destined to gather dust? Have Your Say Is Scottish football stuck in the past? Would you support these changes? Let us know in the comments or join the conversation on social media using #SNNSports

Read More »

New look Scotland begin Nation’s League campaign with defeat to Austria

New interim manager Michael McArdle could not inspire Scotland to victory in the opening game of the Nations League Group A as Lilli Purtscheller fired the Austrians to victory.  Profiting from a mix up at the back, striker Purtscheller was quickest to the ball to open the scoring for the home side with just an a quarter of an hour played. Scotland had dominated the opening exchanges, Kirsty Hanson had an opportunity early on but couldn’t set herself before Caroline Weir took over, only able to muster a tame shot into keeper Manuela Zinsberger. Hanson would return for a second stab almost immediately, latching onto a long ball but unable to get the better of Zinsberger but the Arsenal shot stopper did well to deny the Scotland forward one on one. Momentum soon shifted in favour of the Austrians, Lee Gibson finding herself increasingly busy as the first half wore on, denying Purtscheller a double after the striker did well to turn Jenna Clark. Looking to find their footing in the game, Scotland’s task was made all the more difficult by an early injury to Sophie Howard who hobbled off with substitute Leah Eddie earning her third cap. However the visitors were inches from equalising as debutant Emma Lawton’s leaping header was saved point blank by Zinbsberger who would deny Hanson’s rebound from just a metre out. From there McArdle’s side struggled to generate momentum and were almost caught sleeping for a double as Gibson took too long to play the ball out before Carina Brunold picked her pocket, denied only by a last ditch tackle. In the end Austria were comfortably able to hold out for the three points as Scotland must wait until Tuesday’s home tie against the Netherlands to earn their first points. Lack of impetus costs Scotland Three games without a goal seems all the more baffling a statistic given the wealth of quality Scotland possess with players from Liverpool, Tottenham and Real Madrid on the park. With over three quarters of the game left to play, the side seemed unable to stir up moments to truly trouble an Austrian side looking far too comfortable. Lawton’s header and Hanson’s two efforts came ever so close but in truth they were rarities as the side looked to make up for defensive lapses that began creeping into Scotland’s game with worrying regularity. Amy Muir’s poor clearance the first but Gibson, Clark and Eddie also guilty of errors that fans will not be used to seeing at club level. However there were reasons to be optimistic for supporters. Three debuts on the night with Eilidh Adams and Freya Gregory joining Lawton for first caps. Lawton taking to international football like a fish to water just a few months on from her transition from part-time to professional football after joining Celtic from Partick Thistle. With a group also featuring the Netherlands and Germany, Scotland have it all to do to avoid relegation but they will be buoyed by the presence of new blood who know doubt inject life into a side trying to find its feet in the post-Pedro Martínez Losa era.   Line-ups:  Austria:  Zinsberger, Hanshaw, Kirchberger, Wenger, D’Angelo, Zadrazil (Feiersinger 56), Puntigam (c), Höbinger (Brunold 79), Schasching, Purtscheller, Hickelsberger (Pinther 78) Unused subs: Billa, Brunnthaler, Brunold, Croatto, El Sherif, Georgieva, Kresche, Panther, Rukavina, Schiechtl, Wienroither  Booked: none Goals: Purtscheller 14 Scotland: Gibson, Muir, Howard (Eddie 21), Clark, Lawton, Cornet (Adams 79), Kerr, Weir (c), Hanson, Thomas (Gregory 57), Emslie (Davidson 56) Unused subs: Adams, Clachers, Cumings Budd, MacLean, McCaulay, McLauchlan, Smith, Watson,  Booked: none Goals: none

Read More »

Warsaw magic as Scotland net late winner against Poland

Scotland gave themselves a fighting chance of remaining in the Nations League’s top tier as Andy Robertson’s header in added time condemned the Poles to relegation. It was a rope-a-dope contest from the off but the Scots landed to first blow as John McGinn’s finish, teed up by Ben Doak, gave his side the lead after only three minutes. There were enough permutations to keep even the sharpest producers in the commentators’ ears scrambling but Steve Clarke’s men needed take care of what was in front of them first. As the game wore on Poland showed no signs of letting do so as Jakub Kaminski and Adam Buksa continued to probe for an equaliser. Despite the continued pressure from the home side, it became clear that they were in desperate need of Robert Lewandowski, repeatedly spurning chances without testing the ageless Craig Gordon nearly as much as they should have. Scotland for their part, never settled for a one goal lead, knowing they would need at least another to give themselves the best possible chance of finishing second in the group. A result that would place them amongst the top seeds for the World Cup qualifiers. Not once, but twice did the Scots rattle the bar, Billy Gilmour and Scott McTominay both coming tantalisingly close to edging their side towards the coveted spot. As the second-half bore on both sides began to tire, the end to end action and quick beginning to take its toll on the likes of Doak. With results going their way in Zagreb, Scotland needed to weather the storm but could little as Kamil Piatkowski landed a sucker punch near the hour mark, his thunderous shot from outside the box an impossible proposition for even the most talented keepers. Giving away a lead with the clock running down fast, Steve Clark had been here before. He watched from the sidelines as play maintained its frantic energy, very much at the expense of composure and accuracy. As the final bell approached, the Scots looked weary and out of ideas to prevent their descent into the second tier. That was until John Souttar launched a cross into the box met by a leaping Andy Robertson whose fourth ever goal for his country sent Poland onto the canvas and the Tartan Army into rapture. No top seed but Scots will take heart Whilst Croatia’s equaliser might have put paid to any chance of finishing second in the group and giving Clarke’s men an easier chance of qualification, there was plenty to shout about from the action in Warsaw. Craig Gordon’s inspired performances have made him a clear favourite for the jersey, even when Angus Gunn does make a return from injury. The only person challenging his place between the sticks will be Father Time as Gordon will be forty-three by the time 2026 rolls around. Meanwhile, fans will have been disappointed to see teen sensation Doak leave the field after just over an hour but the late goal shows the side have the tools to win games without relying on one player. Lightening the weight of expectations on his shoulders can only be beneficial to his career in the long run. Finally, Scotland have finally shown they can close out games. The horrors of Portugal, Poland and Croatia in the opening games of their Nations League campaign seemed to have condemned this generation to lack the mental fortitude to cut it at the level that befitted the players’ ability. The previous two victories have instead shown quite the opposite, their resilience giving them the opportunity to continue to test themselves against Europe’s best. They have momentum in the tank, they will now need every drop of it as play-offs potentially await.

Read More »

Scots face battle to retain A-list status in Poland

Nations League – League A – Group 1 – Poland vs Scotland: 19:45 (Stadion Narodowy in Warsaw) With their 1-0 victory over Croatia on Friday night, Scotland’s winless hoodoo finally came to an end. It was a run that had seen the side fail to win their last eight games and was only their second victory in eighteen fixtures. That was all forgotten as they held out against a side, albeit reduced to ten men, featuring the likes of Luka Modric and Josko Gvardiol. Now, a second consecutive win could provide Scotland with the opportunity to right the wrongs of their previous major tournament outings and remain amongst the international a-listers. Doak in the spotlight John McGinn’s goal brought jubilation to the Hampden crowd but it was Ben Doak’s electric performance that has since dominated headlines. Much was made of the way the Middlesborough loanee turned an £80 million defender inside out, and quite rightly as Doak’s gradual introduction into the side has provided the spark Scotland have been missing in the past few years. Clarke however, was quick to remind people that there is room for improvement in his game and has even suggested that Poland might be a game too soon for such a young player. Despite attempts to keep the swirling expectations at bay, it seems unlikely that the manager would not turn to Doak for what could be an era defining ninety minutes in Warsaw. Significant ramifications What seemed an impossible dream only few nights ago now feels like a very distinct possibility as Scotland look to give themselves a platform to qualify for their first World Cup since 1998. Finishing second in Group 1 would give the side the coveted top seeding for the upcoming qualifiers. To do so, they will have to not only beat Poland tonight but hope Portugal can win whilst putting a dent in Croatia’s goal difference, which is two better than Scotland’s. Should results go their way, Steve Clarke’s men would also see themselves make their first ever Nations League quarter-finals. Anything but a win however, would see them relegated and heap the pressure back onto the man in dugout this evening. Poland not to be underestimated A quick scan of Poland’s recent performances will give the Tartan Army some much needed optimism. One win in their last eight including a 5-1 trouncing at the hands of Portugal have left the side looking bereft of confidence. Sitting three points and six goals behind Croatia, their hopes for the second spot are far more difficult, a problem exacerbated by the absence of talisman Robert Lewandowski. However, the Scots will not be quick to forget that their opponent’s sole victory since the Euros came courtesy of a 97th minute penalty at Hampden. Manager Michal Probierz and his side may be down, but they are certainly not out. Conway to be given second start? Fans of the national team are never short of an opinion when it comes to picking a line-up and a boisterous few were finally granted their wish when Tommy Conway was given his first start on Friday. Full of energy and always looking to press, Doak’s Middlesborough teammate made sure Croatia could never pass the ball around comfortably at the back. The striker was not given many opportunities to bring his goalscoring form to Hampden and was brought off for Lyndon Dykes in the second-half, but has given himself every opportunity to start again tonight. Lawrence Shankland’s rut makes him an unlikely candidate and Dykes has yet to score in League One. However, Clarke and supporters will be well aware of the physicality he offers and his hard work to bring other into the game. Scotland desperately need a win with as big a margin as possible, will he trust twenty-two year old Conway to deliver it?  

Read More »

Scotland keep Nations League hopes alive with win over Croatia

Scotland kept their hopes of staying in the Nations League’s top tier alive with a crucial 1-0 victory over Croatia at Hampden Park. Scotland finally broke their Nations League duck and snapped a long winless streak with a dramatic 1-0 victory over Croatia at Hampden Park, thanks to a late strike from substitute John McGinn. McGinn pounced on a rebound after Ben Doak’s shot was parried by Dominik Kotarski, sending Hampden into a frenzy with his 19th international goal. The win breathes life into Scotland’s hopes of staying in Nations League A, with a potential relegation play-off on the line if they secure another result in Poland on Monday. A win in Warsaw could even lead to a Nations League quarter-final spot and a top seed in the World Cup qualifying draw, but only if Croatia lose to Portugal and there’s a significant goal difference swing. For now, though, Steve Clarke’s men will simply celebrate this hard-fought win after 10 competitive games without one. The first half, however, was a nerve-wracking watch for the Tartan Army. Croatia dominated early on, exploiting Scotland’s mistakes. Kenny McLean’s errant pass almost gifted Andrej Kramaric a goal, while Luka Sucic and Kramaric came close to punishing further sloppy play. Craig Gordon’s outstretched foot just about denied Kramaric in the opening 10 minutes. The tide turned in Scotland’s favour when Croatia’s Petar Sucic saw red for a second yellow card in what looked like an innocuous challenge on John Souttar. Croatia were outraged, but the decision shifted the momentum entirely. Scotland regrouped during the break, and the second half was a different story. The introduction of Ben Doak proved pivotal, as the teenager’s pace and energy gave Croatia’s defence nightmares. Doak came close on multiple occasions, while Billy Gilmour squandered a couple of chances to play the youngster through in dangerous positions. Croatia had their moments, with Mario Pasalic narrowly missing after a sublime Luka Modric pass, but the visitors failed to capitalise. When Doak’s late shot caused chaos in the box, McGinn was there to clean up and seal the win. Although Scotland couldn’t find the second goal to give them the head-to-head advantage over Croatia, this result injects much-needed belief into their campaign. The Hampden crowd’s roar at full-time was deafening, but the focus now shifts to Poland, where a win could keep their Nations League dreams alive. The road to recovery is far from over, but Scotland proved they still have fight left in them. Monday’s game is a chance to build on this momentum and finish their campaign on a high.

Read More »

Scotland’s tenure in the UEFA Nations League’s top tier hangs in the balance this Friday, as they face a high-stakes clash against League A Group 1 rivals Croatia.

Scotland’s tenure in the UEFA Nations League’s top tier hangs in the balance this Friday, as they face a high-stakes clash against League A Group 1 rivals Croatia. A loss for the Scots, combined with Poland managing at least a draw against Portugal, would seal their relegation. Even a draw might not be enough, as a surprise Polish victory would push Scotland down the rankings. Meanwhile, Croatia is on the verge of securing a quarter-final spot, adding to the tension of this critical showdown. Though Scotland managed to scrape a hard-fought point last month, their current Nations League campaign has been challenging. After a disappointing Euro 2024 exit, Steve Clarke’s squad began their campaign with three straight defeats, putting them at the bottom of Group 1. Despite a resilient 0-0 draw with group leaders Portugal, Scotland is still in a precarious position, needing results to avoid relegation to League B. The pressure on Clarke has eased slightly after the Portugal result, yet Scotland remains in their longest-ever winless stretch at home (six matches) and is enduring a ten-match drought without a competitive victory. Failure to secure maximum points against Croatia on Friday would see them match their longest winless sequence, last recorded in 1998. The story could have been different; late goals conceded against Portugal and Poland and a contentious VAR decision overturning Che Adams’ equaliser in Zagreb have all cost Scotland crucial points. With two fixtures left, Scotland needs at least four points to avoid automatic relegation. Even third place in the group could lead to a relegation playoff. Croatia, however, has never won in Scotland, their last visit to Hampden in 2013 ending in a 2-0 loss during a World Cup qualifier. Last month, goals from Igor Matanovic and Andrej Kramaric gave Croatia victory over the Scots, but a thrilling 3-3 draw with Poland three days later kept them just shy of securing a quarter-final spot. The 2023 Nations League runners-up enter this game on seven points and are close to advancing to the knockout rounds again. A win in Glasgow, or a draw combined with a Portugal win over Poland, would confirm Croatia’s progress with a game to spare. Croatia’s solid form in the Nations League has been impressive; only Greece has won more games in the last two editions, an achievement considering Croatia’s shaky start, where they lost seven of their first ten Nations League matches. In their last 14 away games, Croatia has scored consistently, averaging over two goals per game. They travel to Glasgow with confidence, looking to exploit a vulnerable Scottish defence. Scotland Nations League form:  LLLD Scotland form (all competitions):  DLLLLD Croatia Nations League form:  LWWD Croatia form (all competitions):  DDLWWD For this clash, Scotland will be boosted by the return of Jack Hendry, John McGinn, and Stuart Armstrong. However, Torino striker Che Adams remains sidelined with a thigh injury, so Tommy Conway, Lyndon Dykes, and Lawrence Shankland are all in contention for a starting spot. Dykes has yet to score in League One, while Shankland has only managed one goal this season, despite an impressive 33-goal haul last term. Supporting the forward line will be McGinn and Scott McTominay, with Napoli’s Billy Gilmour set to challenge Croatia’s midfield maestro Luka Modric. The visitors will be without Lovro Majer and Bruno Petkovic, but Modric and Ivan Perisic bring experience to the squad. Perisic, who has been involved in three goals in two games against Scotland, hasn’t scored in his 18 Nations League appearances. Goalkeeper Dominik Livakovic is suspended, so Augsburg’s Nediljko Labrovic is expected to start in goal. For Scotland, 41-year-old Craig Gordon will continue to deputise for the injured Angus Gunn. Predicted Scotland lineup: Gordon; Ralston, Souttar, Hendry, Robertson; McLean, Gilmour; McGinn, McTominay, Doak; Dykes Predicted Croatia lineup: Labrovic; Sutalo, Caleta-Car, Gvardiol; Perisic, Modric, Kovacic, Sosa; Baturina, Kramaric; Matanovic  

Read More »

Pedro’s Bold Prediction Pays Off as Scotland’s Women Head for Finland

Under the lights at Hibernian’s Easter Road, Scotland’s female national team put on a show. A 4 goal decimation of the Hungarians sets Pedro Martinez Losa’s side up for a mouth-watering play off final tie against Finland as they mount their charge to a place at the Euros next summer.   The lead was taken after 17 minutes and the own goal by Lauren Brzykcy was doubled shortly after by Erin Cuthbert who rifled a shot high past the Hungarian stopper who had a performance to forget. Real Madrid star Caroline Weir added the 3rd after a smart piece of play from Martha Thomas in the 2nd half. Creator turns provider for the 4th goal as Thomas tucks the ball away to seal the game for the Scots. Scotland boss Pedro Martinez Losa was under the spotlight after stating there was “no way” his side would lose at Easter Road and he will be breathing a sigh of relief his team was able to deliver. Martinez Losa has been under fire recently with his squad selections. Criticised for minimising his use of the youth squads with players such as Emma Lawton, Leah Eddie and Eilidh Shore shining at the top level of the Scottish game with Celtic, Rangers and Hearts respectively, being left out and continuing with a team that is aging. Only 3 of the current squad are 23 or younger, but if they make it past Finland and into Euro 2025 then his methods may just be seen to have rewards. On the match, Martinez Losa commented: “We have probably seen the best version of a lot of players and that’s what we want to repeat against Finland. We are two teams at similar levels, we have played against them before and we had the feeling that we could beat them”   Scotland return to Easter Road on the 27th of November for their play off clash against Finland, before heading across the water to play the 2nd leg on the 3rd of December as both teams vie for a place in Switzerland next summer.

Read More »