It only took 53 seconds for this game to burst into life. A free kick whipped in by Mark O’Hara resulted in an acrobatic effort from centre half Richard Taylor flying over the bar. This was the start of a frantic first 10 minutes with the St Mirren defence, in particular, Charles Dunne standing resolute after several crosses from Will Ferry. This would become a familiar feature in the half.

The pace and trickery of Toyosi Olusanya and Roland Idowu caused issues for the Dundee United defence with two penalty claims from the former being waved away by referee Ross Hardie. The home side were urged on by their manager on the touchline to quicken play up, but it wasn’t long before loose kicks from Balcombe and slack play in the middle of the park had the Paisley fans disgruntled in the stands, this followed by ex-Saints manager Jim Goodwin throwing the ball away made for a tense atmosphere at the SMISA stadium. Killian Phillips continued to impress in the black and white with some strong challenges and efforts on goal but ultimately couldn’t break the deadlock. After 20 minutes, the away side should have been 1-0 up.

A free kick was fired in by Will Ferry and met by a free Adegboyega, but the defender scuffs his shot, and the ball is eventually cleared by Charles Dunne. Ross Docherty shows he hasn’t lost it with some nice footwork and switches of play in the middle of the park. United used him wisely in building attacks, with the home side standing firm. Saints grew into the game with Idowu dancing though the Tangerine’s defence before playing a 1-2 with Olusanya but his effort trickles wide of the post. An end-to-
end encounter resulted in tensions spilling over on the touchline with words exchanged between both bosses. As the home side got to grips with the game, Goodwin made a tactical change with striker Jorte Van Der Sande coming off and replaced with winger Glenn Middleton.

The change in formation meant they went toe-to-toe with the home side. This seemed to suit St Mirren as they built a few promising attacks but further efforts from Olusanya were sent over the bar. Before the half time whistle a long throw from Ross
Graham led to a stramash in the box before a shot from a tangerine shirt flew wide of the Saints goal. The first save of the game came from Walton after an effort from Killian Phillips, seconds before the half time whistle.

Half Time: St Mirren 0-0 Dundee United

Dundee United started the half brightly with a couple of half chances and it wasn’t long before the United fans were up in arms with a claim for handball in the 49 th minute but this was checked and cleared by VAR before play continued. The restlessness in the stands continued as a slack pass from O’Hara broke down what looked like a promising Saints attack. The home side struggled to find a rhythm after the break, and it was wave after wave of attack from their opponents who were being rallied on by the 1000 strong away support.

A sight Jim Goodwin didn’t want to see was the injury to experienced centre back Ross Graham who had to be substituted with a suspected hamstring injury. His replacement Kevin Holt was welcomed warmly with his name ringing around the away stand. Eventually a bit of quality came from the home side just before the hour mark. The ball was picked up by Boyd-Munce at the edge of the box before he rifled a shot destined for the top corner if not for an outstanding save from Jack Walton. This looked like it could have been a momentum shifter for St Mirren but instead Dundee United broke straight away and this time it was Balcombe
who collected the ball after a tame effort from Liverpool-loanee Luca Stephenson.

The home side started to live dangerously with the ever-present Marcus Fraser keeping Middleton at bay and it wasn’t long before Robinson made his first changes of the match. The returning Greg Kiltie comes on for Kevin Van Veen as does James Scott for Roland Idowu after 65 minutes. This resulted in a slight shift in formation from a narrow 4-4-2 to a more direct 4-3- 3. The changes seemed to ignite St Mirren for a spell and Killian Phillips left 2 United defenders toiling after some superb footwork before his effort flashes over the bar. Kiltie, a bright spark in this disappointing Saints performance put the Dundee United defence under pressure with his relentless running.

This resulted in a corner which was swung in by his captain Mark O’Hara before meeting the head of Phillips who directs the ball across goal to Olusanya but the Saints man couldn’t find the target. It was then Goodwin’s turn to try and shift the momentum back in his side’s favour, youngster Luca Stephenson was replaced by academy graduate Miller Thomson and minutes later the away side took the lead.

Pandemonium in the away stand followed as a corner was swung in and fell to Docherty at the edge of the box. His volleyed effort stings the palms of Balcombe before the goalkeeper parries it into the path of the onrushing Adegboyega who reacts quickest to head the Jim. Goodwin’s men in front. As the home side try to turn the tide, at 80 minutes Robinson throws on Bwomono, Mandron and minutes later, Smyth as his last roll of the dice in the search for an equaliser.

It was here where the Saints started knocking at the door of the United defence as a header from O’Hara was punched away by Walton and a similar effort as his goal last week ends up over the bar from Phillips. Ultimately, the goal killed any momentum St Mirren had built up but Smyth looked bright in trying to create something in the final few minutes, but Kevin Holt and Declan Gallagher showed their experience and saw clear any danger as the game drew to a close.

Full Time: St Mirren 0-1 Dundee United

Standout Performances

Marcus Fraser. The Saints defender, dubbed “Mr Reliable” by many St Mirren fans nullified the threat of Glenn Middleton and looked bright going forward, linking up well with Idowu down St Mirren’s right-hand side especially in the first half. It was apparent when the former Ross County man moved out of the right back position, Middleton was more of a threat. Ross Docherty. Player of the match and quite rightly so. The Dundee United captain showed his experience and quality in the middle of the pitch. He led by example and dictated everything from back to front for his side and limited any counters from St Mirren. Alongside Craig Sibbald, he covered every blade of grass on the SMISA stadium pitch and after his injury woes he looked back to his ever-composed best.

Tactical Analysis

St Mirren changed from a back 3 to a back 4 due to absences and personnel changes which seemed to catch Dundee United off guard as they tried to match Saints, starting with a 3-5-2. This resulted in the early first half change to counteract Robinson’s men in the 4-3-3.

Dundee United began to exploit the wide areas with Will Ferry in the first half in particular, being given lots of room to pile crosses into the box and drive forward. The change to match their opponents had the potential to go down like a lead balloon but instead Goodwin’s change will be seen as one of merit.