Wilfried Nancy opens up on Celtic exit as former boss claims Parkhead problems ran deeper than results
Former Celtic manager Wilfried Nancy has broken his silence on his brief spell at Parkhead, claiming the club was suffering from “chronic instability” between the board and supporters before his departure.
The Frenchman endured the shortest reign of any permanent Celtic manager in the club’s history after lasting just eight matches following his move from Columbus Crew.
Nancy arrived with the task of challenging for domestic success and improving Celtic’s European performances, but his tenure quickly unravelled after a difficult start.
The 48-year-old suffered defeats against Hearts, Roma and St Mirren in the Premier Sports Cup Final during his opening week, before a loss against Dundee United and a heavy 3-1 defeat to Rangers at Celtic Park brought his time in Glasgow to an abrupt end.
Despite his poor results, Nancy insists his departure was not a reflection of the team’s performances behind the scenes and believes the underlying issues at Celtic had existed long before his arrival.
Speaking on the Sur La Ligne podcast, Nancy said: “It was great because I experienced a new culture, a new environment. Celtic is renowned for what they have achieved.
“The idea was to bring something new. That’s why I was hired. We had to win the Scottish title. We don’t have a choice. But the idea was also to get back on the European scene.
“I knew there were many obstacles. There has been chronic instability for years between the fans and the board.”
Nancy explained that injuries and the pressure surrounding the club made his job more difficult, but he believes his team’s underlying numbers suggested results should have been better.
“When I arrived, there were a lot of games and a lot of players who were injured. The idea was to go there and get things in place,” he added.
“Afterwards, unfortunately, it became a bit irrational.
“In terms of performance, there were some really interesting things. We should have been winning matches.
“The performance indicators showed we should have won games by two or three goals. But no, we lost a few games. Then a bit of fear set in regarding our results.”
Nancy also pointed out that Celtic were still close to the Premiership leaders when the decision was made to remove him.
“We still won some games, but they decided we wouldn’t continue together, even though we were second and only three points behind first place.”
Following Nancy’s exit, Celtic turned back to experienced manager Martin O’Neill, who guided the club to a Premiership and Scottish Cup double during his return spell.
The former Columbus Crew boss also suggested that his attempts to introduce new ideas into Scottish football were met with resistance.
“The Scots aren’t quite ready to adapt,” Nancy said. “I’m not generalising.
“They have a way of doing things, and they struggle a bit to change some of their ways of doing things, so I tried to implement it.
“There was some resistance, but that’s part of my story, and thanks to that period, I feel even stronger because I learned even more.”
Nancy’s comments are likely to reignite debate among Celtic supporters, with questions continuing around the relationship between the club’s hierarchy and the fanbase.
While his short spell on the touchline ended in disappointment, the former MLS-winning coach believes his time at Celtic Park highlighted deeper challenges beyond what happened on the pitch.
2 Responses
This guy is unbelievable and far too full of his own importance. He got a healthy severance package after 4 weeks disruption of my team and he really should just keep quiet. Let him come back and start singing when he’s proved himself and his tactics elsewhere. In any event st Celtic we have no interest in him and is a proven failure. Enough said.
Nancy won 2 games of 8 managed.
First was against bottom of the league, where Celtic went behind twice (in the first 10mins) before winning against a team that was ultimately relegated.
Second win was against a bottom half of the table team where result stood at 1-1 after 88mins.
First defeat was after Nancy been in 4 days. He changed the formation and system from the midweek match under previous manager. Had to show the captain several times on a tactics board visible on live tv what he wanted to happen (with opposing manager also watching over his shoulder). Game was lost, at home, to team’s main rival at that point.
European game then lost, at home 0-3.
Cup Final then lost 1-3 to a team that, at the end of the season, only avoided relegation through a play off.
Next league game then lost to a bottom half of the table team after being a goal up.
Played one acceptable half of football against biggest local rivals in derby match, then capitulated, at home again, in losing 3 second half goals. Defeated 1-3.
The manager the team had before Nancy and after him (same 73 year old Manager) overcame the club’s apparent, player / supporter / injury/ Board / structural / cultural inadequacies and still managed to win the league with the last kick of the season.
So it would appear the club got rid of Nancy just in the nick of time to avoid a trophy-less season.
Cup final was then won the following week too. All supporters can see EXACTLY where the immediate problem lay. And his name was Nancy. Good riddance.